top of page

WeldTips #6: MIG Spatter or Burn-Through? Your Transfer Mode Might Be the Problem.

1 day ago
5 min read

Closeup of MIG welding sparks.



MIG welding variables include wire size, current, arc length, travel speed, electrode angle, etc.


Ask any welder in the shop and they'll happily tell you everything you're doing wrong. Fit-up, parameters, equipment, take your pick.


When MIG welding, there are a myriad of variables and factors that should be considered while you are engineering the perfect weld. These can include wire size, current, arc length, travel speed, electrode angle, etc. Due to the vast amount of variables involved, it goes without saying that there are almost infinite ways to put down a weld with less than desirable qualities.




Some problems are fixed with better fit-up.


Some are fixed with wire and gas selection.


And some are avoided entirely by picking the right MIG transfer mode before you strike an arc...





The three MIG transfer modes


Your transfer mode determines how metal from the wire is deposited into the molten weld pool. It changes your penetration, spatter, heat input and overall production efficiency. The three you'll run into most are short circuit, spray and pulse.


Each of these modes have their own advantages and understanding their strengths can help fabricators to increase weld quality and reduce rework. Here's what each one does well, where it gets you into trouble, and how to pick the right one for the job. Your shielding gas and settings will also be a factor when deciding which ones you can run.



  1. SHORT CIRCUIT

 

HOW IT WORKS

Repeated contact between the wire and the weld pool, shorting out and re-arcing many times a second. This will produce a sound similar to the crackle of bacon frying.


BEST FOR

Thin material, sheet metal and root passes. Heat input is lower, so you get less burn-through and less distortion on heat-sensitive parts. It works in flat, horizontal, vertical and overhead positions, which is helpful when you can't reposition the part.


WATCH OUT FOR

More spatter and can lead to more post-weld cleaning in industries that prioritize a clean weld appearance. The lower current also limits its penetration on thicker material.


GAS & EQUIPMENT

Any conventional MIG power source, and does not require a specific gas mixture.

 


  1. SPRAY


HOW IT WORKS

Higher current allows for a continuous stream of fine metal droplets to transfer across the arc. When it's set right, you get a stable arc with very little spatter and will sound like a steady hiss. It is also compared to the sound of wind through leaves.


BEST FOR

Thicker material in the flat and horizontal positions. Spray allows for good penetration and a clean bead, and the high deposition rate means faster welding. This makes Spray transfer a workhorse in production environments that put down a lot of weld metal and work with thicker base materials. 


WATCH OUT FOR

High heat input. If you don't plan for it, you'll get burn-through, distortion or other quality problems. The puddle is very fluid, which makes out-of-position welding hard to control. Stick to flat and horizontal.


GAS & EQUIPMENT

You need at least 80% argon in your shielding gas to get a stable spray arc. Any industrial MIG power source works with the right gas and settings.

 


  1. PULSE


HOW IT WORKS

Pulse (also called pulsed spray or pulse MIG) is modern welding engineers' attempt to have your cake and eat it too. The power source switches rapidly between a high peak current and a lower background current which allows for the benefits of both Spray and Short-Circuit. The peak current gives you the heat needed for proper fusion. The background current lets the puddle cool slightly, which keeps overall heat input down.


BEST FOR

Jobs where you want spray-like deposition and penetration but need more control over heat. Spatter is low, and the controlled heat lets you weld vertically and overhead. There are many pulse programs with different current patterns, but they share those strengths.


WATCH OUT FOR

Equipment. Not every MIG machine can run pulse programs. 


GAS & EQUIPMENT

A pulse-capable power source is required. If you have one, pulse is a strong choice when you want the benefits of spray with more control over heat. Pulse also requires 80% Argon in your shielding gas.



Which mode fixes my problem?

If you're seeing this

Try

Why

Burn-through on thin sheet

Short circuit or pulse

Lower or controllable heat input

Distortion on heat-sensitive parts

Short circuit or pulse

Less heat going into the part

Too much spatter cleanup

Spray or pulse

Calmer puddle leads to low spatter

Slow production

Spray or pulse

High deposition rate



Short circuit vs. spray vs. pulse at a glance


Short circuit

Spray

Pulse

Heat input

Low

High

Moderate

Spatter

High

Low

Low

Penetration

Can be limited on thicker material

Good

Good

Thin material

Well suited 

Higher burn-through risk

Well suited

Positions

All

Flat and horizontal

All

Deposition rate

Low

High

High

These are general comparisons, not fixed rules. Results depend on your equipment, wire, shielding gas, material, joint prep and weld procedure.



How a robot can help


It eliminates other factors.

When inspecting a weld, it is impossible to tell if the spatter you are seeing is coming from bad parameters or from the welding torch drifting too far away from the puddle. A robot gives you consistent control of variables like stickout and travel speed, allowing you to focus completely on parameters and transfer modes.


It makes heat input predictable. 

Travel speed is part of heat input. Slow down at a corner or pause to reposition, and a thin sheet can burn through. A robot runs the same speed from start to finish, so settings that work on the straight welds still work on the corners.


It gives you more control over position. 

Spray is fast but requires flat and horizontal positions. With a robotic positioner turning the part, more joints are available where spray works best.



Choosing the transfer mode is a welder's call.


A robot doesn't make it for you. Robots will maintain consistent travel speed, torch angle, and contact tip-to-work distance. However, proper joint preparation, part fixturing, shielding gas selection, and weld procedure development remain essential.




—From the Productive Robotics Weld Team


Productive Robotics is the original American cobot company. We manufacture the world's broadest line of collaborative welding robots and cells. Plus our OB7™ cobot series automates unlimited applications, including CNCs, palletizing, assembly and deburring.


  • No robot experience needed.

  • No code. Demonstrate the weld path by hand to teach. 

  • 7-axis arm design for more approach angles, reach and less re-fixturing.


Designed, built and supported in the USA.

Have a question about your parts?

Talk with a welding and robotics expert:

805-244-9300


30 pages on how to automate MIG and laser welding.



Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page